The Editorial Juris
JC
Back to Prospects
Diane Prescott
Medical Malpractice · Agent: David Miller
March 13, 2026 · 9:45 AM
Good morning, Ms. Prescott. This is David Miller from The Editorial Juris. Thank you for reaching out. I understand you experienced complications after a surgical procedure. Can you tell me more about what happened?
Yes. I had a routine gallbladder removal last year, and during the surgery, my bile duct was damaged. I ended up back in the hospital for three weeks with infections and had to have two additional corrective surgeries. It's been a nightmare.
I'm very sorry you went through that, Ms. Prescott. Bile duct injuries during cholecystectomy, while not unheard of, are considered a deviation from the standard of care when they occur due to surgical error. The fact that you required extended hospitalization and corrective procedures suggests the initial surgery may not have been performed with the expected level of skill and caution. We would have a medical expert review your surgical records to assess exactly where the deviation occurred.
REBUTTAL DETECTED: Standard of Care
But my surgeon told me that complications like this 'just happen sometimes' and that it's a known risk of the procedure. He made it sound like nobody did anything wrong.
Surgeons often frame complications that way, and while bile duct injury is a recognized risk, that doesn't automatically absolve the surgeon of responsibility. The key question is causation — was the injury a result of a specific surgical error, or was it truly an unavoidable complication despite proper technique? Our medical experts review the operative notes, imaging, and pathology to determine exactly what happened. In many cases, what surgeons call 'a known risk' turns out to be a preventable error.
REBUTTAL DETECTED: Causation
That makes sense. I've always felt like something went wrong, but I didn't know how to challenge what the doctor said.
You don't have to challenge it alone. That's what our team and our medical consultants are for. We review the records independently and objectively. If the evidence supports a malpractice claim, we'll present you with a clear assessment and recommended path forward.
I'd like that. The medical bills from the corrective surgeries have been overwhelming, and I missed months of work.
Those are exactly the kinds of damages — medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering — that a malpractice claim can address. Let me get your records request started so our medical team can begin their review. I'll walk you through every step.
Thank you, David. I appreciate you taking the time to explain everything. Let's proceed.
Call Summary
85
AI Score
Confidence85%
Duration: 5m 55s
Rebuttals: 2 detected
Supervisor Feedback
Tone & Professionalism
110
Compliance
110
Objection Handling
110
Outcome / Conversion
110